December 23, 2007 at 6:17 pm (Alternative Medicine, Bad Science, government, Homeopathic Remedies, Homeopathy, Remedies) (, , , , , , )

The Department of Health (DoH) has responded to my query on homeopathy with the following:

“We recognise that many people find complementary and alternative medicine helpful in alleviating the symptoms of certain illnesses, especially those illnesses for which orthodox medicine does not appear to offer a complete answer. We also appreciate the fact that the public is increasingly making use of complementary and alternative treatments and products, including homeopathy.”
‘Many people…’, ‘the public is increasingly making use of…’. Now, that just sounds like an appeal to popularity, doesn’t it? Or perhaps it’s a circular argument: people use it, therefore people are justified in using it.

“We consider that decision making on individual clinical interventions, whether orthodox or complementary treatments, is a matter for local NHS service providers and practitioners as they are best placed to know their community’s needs.”

In making such decisions, they have to take into account evidence of the safety, clinical and cost-effectiveness, the availability of suitably qualified practitioners, and the needs of the individual patient. Clinical responsibility rests with the NHS professional who makes the decision to refer and who must therefore be able to justify any treatment they recommend.”
If the NHS professionals making the decision to refer have to take into account evidence of the clinical effectiveness of the treatment and justify the treatment, how is it possible for homeopathy to be available on the NHS?

“PCTs often have specific policies on the extent to which patients can be given access to complementary and alternative therapies and, within these policies, it is open to GPs to give access to specific therapies, including homeopathy, where they consider it in the interests of the individual patient”
So, homeopathic remedies must first pass the twin barriers of local PCT and GP before they are flogged to (possibly unsuspecting) patients. [Some people who take homeopathic remedies don’t realise that they are being sold ‘medicines’ containing no active ingredient, possibly because homeopathy is sometimes equated with herbal medicine. If you want to know more about homeopathy, follow the links from this previous blog post]

I wonder if my local PCT has a policy on CAM.


  1. gimpy said,

    It’s just buck passing isn’t it? This is how alternative (as opposed to complementary) treatments sneak into the NHS. No one wants the responsibility of being the person who ‘just says no’ to alternative health. Politicians do it as well, its a terrible cowardice, managers and politicians are just so scared of offending communities or organisations that they equivocate and waffle rather than castigate the woowoo merchants. Fuck ’em I say.

  2. ambrielle said,

    NHS/PCT’s seem to find it easy enough to close beds or wards, or cut nursing staff. You would think it would be easier to not to fund the alt. therapies. After all, they aren’t unionised. Or sane.

  3. DOH Email On CAM « Stuff And Nonsense said,

    […] It looks to be roughly the same format as the email response I got when I contacted the DoH to complain about homeopathy on the NHS a while back (blogged here: D’oh!). […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: